As you near graduation, you are likely wondering if I were to get a job offer at a big 4 vs boutique consultancy which should I pick? Frequently the consideration is mainly about brand name recognition and prestige, however there are many reasons to also consider other aspects.
Career advancement between big 4 and boutique consulting firms
The first thing to consider is career advancement between the two. Big 4 firms offer a great deal of structure and career advancement opportunities after a few years. Often just a few years is enough to exit into a solid industry role. However, when it comes to moving up beyond the manager level at the big 4, this is often very difficult, with many taking years to advance to senior manager and director levels.
For career advancement at boutique firms, it initially starts off similar to the big 4, however there is often less difficulty in advancing up to the director level, especially for consultants whom develop strong client relationships and niche skillsets. Unlike the big 4, a consultant might be the sole person with the right skills and connections on certain projects and clients, while in the big 4, the vastness of the talent pool often means there is always a team of specialists. Exit opportunities for boutique consultants are also strong, however it might be more limited to the region or specialties that the boutique firm operates in.
Salary between big 4 and boutique consulting firms
Salary is another area of difference between big 4 and boutique consultancies. Big 4 firms often offer better salary packages with strong benefits. This isn’t to say that boutique firms cannot offer these, however since boutique firms often benchmark against local companies in the region, they frequently offer packages that are slightly less competitive.
Network and firm culture between big 4 and boutique consulting firms
Network and firm culture is another important aspect. Big 4 firms offer a incredibly vast global network of talent to connect with and learn from. This also gives strong relocation opportunities to other geographies. Firm culture wise, this can vary quite significantly from department to department, however there is generally a minimum size of clients and projects that big 4 firms will engage in. This minimum size means that firm culture closely mirrors those of other big corporates. There are variations between departments, but generally the difference is quite muted.
At boutique firms, firm culture is more uniform given the smaller size. Often most teams are familiar with each other and there is more flexibility to switch teams. Working with smaller clients also means that the firm retains its own culture rather than getting absorbed into the culture of big corporates. While the size of the professional network is smaller, connections are often much deeper and alumni are often willing to go further to support each other later in careers.
Conclusion
In the end, both big 4 and boutique consultancies offer strong career opportunities, cultures, and networks. Which one is best for you depends on your preferences and what you are looking to achieve in your career.
About PrepareConsult:
PrepareConsult is a platform to practice the consulting case interview with AI and peers. PrepareConsult is founded by Milad Mohammadi and Sahhas Nathella.
Milad Mohammadi – 7+ years of experience in consulting and professional services with experience across North America and Europe.
Sahhas Nathella – 5+ years of experience in consulting and professional services with strong experience in complex digital transformations.
PrepareConsult 